Baileys Eggnog: Get into the Holiday Spirit with a Creamy Cocktail

This baileys eggnog recipe was first published on October 30, 2023.

Christmas, as you know, it’s a very big deal around here. We LOVE Christmas and for the past few years, we have been sharing recipes right, left and centre. That is the kind of devotion we have towards the best time of the year. So, this year, we’re kicking the season off with a favourite of ours, the Baileys Eggnog.

We have made eggnog before, a spicy and kid-friendly concoction we ended up drinking within days. But let me just tell you, this adult-only version with the addition of Baileys is a completely different story. So, with the holiday season upon us, what better way to celebrate than by whipping up a festive and indulgent Baileys Eggnog Cocktail? Baileys Irish Cream, a delightful and original Irish cream liqueur, pairs perfectly with the rich and creamy eggnog to create a luscious holiday drink.

In this blog post, we’ll walk you through the steps to create this delightful cocktail, complete with all the flavours and spices that scream Christmas. So, grab your cinnamon stick and get ready to make some holiday magic!

This post about Baileys Eggnog contains affiliate links and we may earn a small commission when you click on the links at no additional cost to you. We would only recommend products we use and love ourselves; all opinions expressed here are our own. Please read our Privacy Policy here. Thank you!

The Christmas Devotion

While I am more than happy to share the recipe for this Baileys Eggnog, I thought I could share some of my favourites from the last few years:

• these Christmas Pudding chocolate biscuits, too adorable and extremely easy to bake;
• the traditional Duck à L’Orange you need to serve as a chic option;
• this vegan mushroom Wellington which is as delicious as it gets;
• some vegan hot chocolate cookies for the cold evenings;
• the king of Christmas, this pistachio panettone for the sweet cravings;
• a delicious pavlova with citrus and nuts;
• keeping up with traditions and the mince pies that are easy and quick;
• this gingerbread pavlova is to die for;
• we also have a gingerbread syrup, perfect for coffees and cocktails alike;
• cranberry whipped feta dip, to entertain your guests since the appetizer;
• bourbon berry pie, because what is a Christmas lunch with no dessert;
• some of my favourite rosemary parmesan shortbread cookies;
• a delicious main with this brie stuffed pork tenderloin recipe;
• an easy christmas focaccia;
• these quick and easy christmas sausage rolls;
• simple and delicious christmas biscotti recipe;
• a classic like pistachio panettone;
• the most delicious and easy brie galette;
• a treat for your furry friends with these dog’s gingerbread cookies and some for humans too;
• and lastly, the latest hot toddy mocktail!
• the vegan clementine curd for Christmas breakfast.

With so many more available already, and plenty of new ones coming your way, our blog is most definitely your go-to for all your food needs this coming Christmas!

Let’s get shaking this Baileys Eggnog

The whole deal with this Baileys Eggnog is that there isn’t another cocktail as quick to whip up as this one. With barely any work involved, you’ll be pouring spiked eggnogs in no time. But let’s have a look at the ingredients and process now.

What is Baileys Irish Cream?

Before we dive into making the ultimate Baileys Eggnog, let’s start with the star of the show, Baileys Irish Cream. This original Irish cream liqueur has been a favourite for decades and is known for its smooth and creamy taste. It’s made with high-quality Irish whiskey and a special blend of dairy cream and cocoa, creating a harmonious marriage of flavours that is truly unforgettable.

Baileys Irish Cream is a versatile liqueur that can be enjoyed neat, on the rocks, in coffee, or as a key ingredient in a variety of cocktails. During the holiday season, it takes centre stage in festive recipes like our Baileys Eggnog Cocktail.

Why Choose Baileys for Your Eggnog Cocktail?

When it comes to making a creamy and delicious eggnog cocktail, there’s no better choice than Baileys Irish Cream. Here’s why:

• Creaminess: Baileys is renowned for its velvety, creamy texture, which pairs perfectly with the richness of eggnog. It creates a luxurious and indulgent drink that’s perfect for sipping by the fire;
• Flavour: The combination of Baileys’ Irish whiskey and the original Irish cream flavour is unparalleled. It adds depth and complexity to your eggnog cocktail, making it stand out in a crowded field of holiday drinks;
• Quality: Baileys has a reputation for using the finest ingredients, resulting in a high-quality product that consistently delivers on its promise of taste and excellence. You can trust Baileys to elevate your eggnog cocktail to perfection.

Now that you know why Baileys is the ideal choice for your holiday concoction, let’s move on to the ingredients you’ll need to make your Baileys Eggnog Cocktail a reality.

What ingredients do I need to make this Baileys eggnog?

Very basic ingredients are required for this Baileys eggnog, so let’s see them together:

• Egg: Eggnog’s rich and creamy base is derived from egg yolks. The yolks add a velvety texture and a luscious, custard-like flavour to the drink. When it comes to making your own eggnog, using fresh, high-quality eggs is essential. The egg yolks are whisked with white sugar, creating a sweet and smooth foundation for the drink. This classic combination is the canvas upon which the other ingredients work their magic;
• White sugar: White sugar is the sweetener of choice for eggnog, providing the necessary sweetness to balance the rich, savoury flavours of egg yolks. It’s not only about sweetness, though; the sugar helps to create a smooth and silky texture in your eggnog. The sweetness of the sugar is essential to offset the warming spices like cinnamon and nutmeg;
• Milk: Milk is the liquid component that gives eggnog its characteristic creamy quality. Whole milk is the traditional choice, but you can customize your eggnog by using different types of milk, like 2%, skim, or even a dairy-free alternative. The milk dilutes the richness of the egg yolks, making the drink more sippable and palatable;
• Vanilla paste: Vanilla paste, derived from vanilla beans, adds a depth of flavour and aromatic complexity to your Baileys eggnog. It enhances the sweetness while providing a subtle but distinct vanilla aroma. The tiny black specks of vanilla in your eggnog give it a gourmet touch, and it pairs harmoniously with the warm spices in the mix;
• Cinnamon & Nutmeg: Cinnamon and nutmeg are the spices that transform ordinary eggnog into a seasonal delight. Cinnamon imparts a sweet, slightly spicy note, while nutmeg offers a nutty, warm flavour with a hint of earthiness. The combination of these spices awakens the senses and invokes the feeling of cosiness and nostalgia;
• Baileys: And now, the star of the show, Baileys Irish Cream. Baileys is a luxurious, original Irish cream liqueur made from Irish whiskey, dairy cream, and cocoa. When added to eggnog, it brings a whole new dimension of flavour. The creamy richness of Baileys perfectly complements the egg yolks and milk, creating a smooth and velvety texture. Furthermore, the hint of whiskey in Baileys blends seamlessly with the nutmeg and cinnamon, enhancing the drink’s overall complexity.

Baileys adds a touch of indulgence to your eggnog, making it a truly special holiday treat. Whether you prefer a classic eggnog recipe or like to experiment with different variations, adding Baileys is a fantastic way to elevate the flavours and create a delightful, adult-friendly twist on a traditional favourite.

How Do I make this Baileys Eggnog?

Making an eggnog, even a Baileys eggnog, it’s pretty easy. Let’s see how we can put it together now.

Step 1: Prepare Your Glass

Before you start mixing your cocktail, you’ll want to create a festive atmosphere with your glass. Here’s how:

• Take a small plate and pour a bit of brown sugar onto it;
• Pour some milk into a separate bowl and then dip the rim of your glass;
• Gently press the moistened rim of the glass into the brown sugar to create a sugared rim.

This simple step adds a touch of sweetness and sparkle to your cocktail presentation.

Step 2: Mix the Base

Now, let’s get to the heart of the recipe:

• In a small bowl, beat the egg yolk and white sugar until they are light and fluffy and the sugar has completely dissolved in the yolk;
• Grab your cocktail shaker and add the yolk and sugar mixture, the milk, the Baileys and the vanilla paste;
• Add a pinch of ground nutmeg and a pinch of ground cinnamon to the mixture.

Step 3: Shake It Up

• Fill your shaker or glass with ice;
• Put the lid on your shaker or use a spoon to stir the mixture until it’s well combined and chilled.

Step 4: Pour and Garnish

• Strain your mixture into your prepared glass;
• Grate a bit of fresh nutmeg on top of the drink and a dust of cinnamon for a touch of elegance and flavour;
• Finally, add a cinnamon stick for garnish, and your Baileys Eggnog is ready to impress!

Tips for the Perfect Baileys Eggnog Cocktail

Creating the perfect Baileys Eggnog Cocktail is an art, and every artist needs some tips to achieve perfection. Here are some handy tips to ensure your holiday drink is a hit:

• Use Fresh Eggnog: The freshness of your eggnog is crucial. Opt for high-quality, fresh eggnog for the best results;
• Choose the Right Glass: Presentation matters, so select a glass that showcases your cocktail’s festive look;
• Don’t Overdo It: While the addition of Irish whiskey can be delightful, be mindful of the quantity. You want to enhance the flavour, not overpower it;
• Grate Fresh Nutmeg: Whenever possible, grate fresh nutmeg. The aroma and flavour are incomparable to pre-ground nutmeg;
• Customize to Your Taste: Feel free to adjust the ingredients to suit your personal preferences. Whether you like it sweeter, spicier, or boozier, make it your own;
• Serve Chilled: Make sure your cocktail is well-chilled. This enhances the creamy texture and the overall experience.

Baileys Eggnog Variations

While the classic Baileys Eggnog Cocktail is a winner, there are plenty of ways to get creative with this holiday treat. Here are a few variations to consider:

• Chocolate Lover’s Twist: Add a drizzle of chocolate syrup to your cocktail for a delightful chocolatey kick;
• Spice It Up: Experiment with different spices like cloves or allspice to give your drink a unique twist;
• Non-Alcoholic Version: Omit the Irish whiskey for a kid-friendly, non-alcoholic version that everyone can enjoy;
• Frozen Baileys Eggnog: Blend your ingredients with ice for a chilled, frozen treat;
• Caramel Cinnamon Delight: Drizzle some caramel syrup over the whipped cream and sprinkle a little extra cinnamon for an extra layer of flavour.

Shop the Baileys Eggnog post

The Baileys Eggnog Cocktail is a perfect way to usher in the holiday season. Whether you’re sipping it by the fireplace, enjoying it with friends and family, or simply indulging in some self-care, this cocktail is sure to bring warmth and joy to your festivities.

With the creamy goodness of Baileys Irish Cream, the classic flavour of eggnog, and the aromatic spices of cinnamon and nutmeg, it’s the ultimate holiday drink. And with our exclusive recipe rating system, you can trust that you’re getting a top-notch recipe.

Pin this Baileys Eggnog Recipe for Later!